So after seeing
the movie a second time, I realized that I didn't really need to put off reviewing it. My opinion didn't change at all. It was just as enjoyable (VERY enjoyable), but the things that bothered me the first time around still bothered me.
Generally speaking, I really feel like the movie stayed true to the book. The casting was incredible (Bella, and ALL of the Cullens. And Jessica.). There were some changes to the plot, but they mostly made sense to me. No book translates directly onto film, and changes are to be expected. I get irritated with changes when I don't understand the reason behind them (Faramir? Why aren't you letting Frodo go? And who knows what in the world happened to Eragon...), but there was only one thing in this movie that didn't make sense to me, and it was very trivial (more on this below). Either way, if you let yourself get caught up in that, you'll never enjoy a book made from a movie ever. I will say that some of the stuff that was left out is going to have to be explained more in upcoming movies if they plan on sticking as close to the book as they did in this movie. But, it wasn't anything major that can't be worked out.
Some of the cinematography was pretty awkward. And the acting was a bit shaky in parts... in lots of parts. Which is one of the major reasons the movie cannot have an A. But, overall, the actors--especially
Kristen Stewart (Bella) and
Rob Pattinson (Edward) did well portraying the characters as they are in the book. And seriously, the casting was awesome.
When I first saw the movie, I was thinking that someone who hadn't read the book wouldn't enjoy it at all. But then my
brother-in-law went with my
sister and really liked it. He had a few questions about things that my sister had to explain, but overall he enjoyed it. Especially a certain scene that involved some baseball...
Okay, I'm going to get more specific from this point on. If you haven't read the books, it will mean serious SPOILERS. If you have read the books, but still want to not know the details of the movie, the same applies.
About some of the changes in the movie: My sister mentioned one to me, that I think is a good example of how easy some of these changes are to explain. She was irritated that Jacob wasn't the one that told Bella the whole story of the vampires. "Why did she have to learn from a book?" But really, having her learn such a crucial piece of information in one conversation makes for a short sequence in a movie. In a book its fine, but dragging it out so that she has to do a bit more research translates to better suspense in film. It has to be a longer process so that viewers can really identify with it, right?
One of the big issues I had going it to it was that I knew about the climbing of the trees and jumping around in the tree tops. This, of course, is not a part of the books and I was worried about how they'd fit that it. I totally got it though. Especially with the lines, "Things like this just don't exist." "They do in my world." Running through the treetops was a way to show the heightened beauty and awe of the world the Cullens lived in. Good call
Catherine Hardwicke and
Melissa Rosenberg.
I do think the movie could have been a bit longer. They fit in all the important points and plot lines and character development. But I missed some of the more minor nuances. We didn't even get to learn about Jasper's enhanced abilities. We didn't really get a lot of Jasper at all, which I sad about. I did really enjoy the description, "The blond one that looks like he's in pain." Poor Jessica has no idea... I wanted more of Emmet too. And Alice. Especially Alice and her influence over everyone's wardrobe. And I wanted more of Carlisle's background. I think with another 20 minutes these things could have been covered. Of course, they might not have had the budget for it...
Some specific things I really enjoyed:
- The look on Edward's face every time he kissed Bella.
- Robert Pattinson's portrayal of Edward. I'd read beforehand that Stephenie Meyer had given him a copy of what she had written of Midnight Sun before filming, and I think the fact that he incorporated that is evident. I loved it.
- Bella's klutzy moments. I was so pleased when she slipped on the ice.
- Stephenie Meyer's cameo. Even though she didn't say anything, it was just fun to see her in the movie.
- The quick Little Brown and Co. reference while Bella was internet searching.
Some things I really hated:
- The first biology scene when Edward smells Bella for the first time. It was totally overacted and came off comical. Its fine to accept it as a funny scene... but it wasn't meant to be.
- Those STUPID sunglasses. #1. Its not sunny. If it were sunny, Edward, you'd not be walking around outside. #2 They did NOT look good. Alice would NEVER have approved.
- That STUPID converse. I get that its what Bella would do... but its NOT what Alice would do. This is the one change that I hated and did not understand. "Alice lent me the dress." But not shoes?!?! That's not an oversight Alice would make. Tsk Tsk
In other good news, the movie seems to have done well enough in its first couple of days that
Summit Entertainment has announced they are officially doing
New Moon. Woo Hoo!